-
Gary Randazzo ●
- 5 stars Rating: 98
2016 votes total - Gary Randazzo
- (11285)
- 33 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 5 stars
-
wineknow said...
Does Arizona have some silly requirement that students must have a H.S. diploma? Because if not, I say we offer him a scholarship NOW. He's better than Mayes, right now. He's WAAAAAY better than Turner.
I was disappointed to see him shooting, the assists were INSANE. This is the best 2 minutes I've seen out of a pint guard since Mike Bibby. Compare that to the Utube video posted here on Gabe York where all he did was shoot and thump his own chest.
-
uofasteve said...
sometimes I think you just post out of your ass... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3QsQ-X__qBk Josiah Turner was the best point guard in the country last year for a freshman. He had no help on the inside which really limited his ability to drive the lanes, and make the big passes to the post players. his jump shot was always the weak spot in his game. now, this doesn't mean Josiah wasnt a problem player. I'd much rather have a point guard with slightly less skill the the other players like because it makes court chemistry better.
"Arizona has no tradition" - Bill Walsh "We have a tradition of kicking Bill Walsh's ass" - Teddy Bruschi
-
wineknow said...
You are kidding, right? Best freshmen PG in the country? By the end of the year he was barely the third best freshmen on his team and only that because one guy didn't show up. Chol has far more upside.
You watched these two videos of kids 6 years different in age and you think Turner is better? Could it be because Turner can dunk? News flash: least import skill for a POINT guard is the ability to dunk. MOST important skill is ball handling/passing. If that kid reaches 5'10" tall he's a one and done. Oh wait I keep forgetting - The NBA doesn't run any type of offense any more, it's all about one on one - they don't really need or use point guards anymore.
Both were playing against lesser players, but there was a far greater distance between Thronton and his peers than Turner. Further more what the hell happened to Turner last year - we didn't see any of the player in that video. If I had to guess what John Stockton or Jason Kidd or Mike Bobby would look right now as an 8th grader - Thronton is my guess. He was making passes Josiah Turner couldn't see if he was on acid and is already way beyond anywhere Josiah will ever be.
Turner played about 11 minutes worth of good basketball last year, interspersed with hours of very average at best performance. I don't think anyone could look at these two clips and think Turner is a better point guard or basketball player.
-
Gary Randazzo ●
- 5 stars Rating: 98
2016 votes total - Gary Randazzo
- (11285)
- 33 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 5 stars
-
Gary Randazzo said...
Honestly, you need to drop the recruiting hype stuff. Turner dominated opponents at the high school level. At some point you have to blame the athlete for not putting in the work to improve as a player. Every time you jump a level (high school to college to professional) an athlete needs to up their effort level, condition harder, and practice with more focus to excel on the court. Turner didn't put in enough of the work off the court to excel on the court. That said, there were "concerns" prior to college already apparent. For me, perhaps my biggest concern was how "quiet" Josiah was. When I'm evaluating true PGs, I want to see a talker on the court, someone demanding excellence from their teammates, and someone who knows the offense better than anyone. Josiah, even in high school, didn't demonstrate that type of leadership.
As for young Derryck Thorton, I got a good long look at him this past weekend. He handled himself well against the 2013 and 2014 players. The kid's got some guts, and smartly recognized that the best way for him to compete against older and stronger guys was to bust his ass on the defensive end of the floor, which to his credit he did. I have an awesome photo of him in a defensive stance that I'll post here in a bit.
"Arizona has no tradition" - Bill Walsh "We have a tradition of kicking Bill Walsh's ass" - Teddy Bruschi
-
BradAllis
- 5 stars Rating: 89
1086 votes total - Brad Allis
- (5363)
- 33 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 5 stars
-
BradAllis said...
2. Don't blame York for the videos out there on him. Most of those are professionally done hype videos. Site's know that dunks and highlight reel plays are what attract viewers. Most people out there looking for highlights don't want to see fundamentals. Harder to find are true highlight/recruiting videos. These are usually put out by a recruit's family or coaches and are evaluated by college coaches. You see these more in football than hoop.
-
BradAllis said...
1. You have to treat recruiting rankings for what they are, predictors of future success. Think of them like the SAT. A kid who scores a 1600 on the SAT is MORE LIKELY to succeed in college than a kid with a 900, but there are no guarantees. More 5-stars than 4-stars excel in college, but not all. There are always exceptions. That being said, if you look at the history of Arizona basketball, more elite recruits work out than don't. For every Turner, there are 10 Bibby's, Elliott's, Budinger's, Gardner's, etc. The good news is that Arizona is also able to find the Steve Kerr's and Derrick Williams' of the world.
There are busts like Turner (off court issues) There are players who have nice careers but fail to live up to the hype like Shakur (4-year starter) and Jawann McClellan (injuries/off court issues), but there are plenty of 4 and 5 star kids who have shined.
2. Don't blame York for the videos out there on him. Most of those are professionally done hype videos. Site's know that dunks and highlight reel plays are what attract viewers. Most people out there looking for highlights don't want to see fundamentals. Harder to find are true highlight/recruiting videos. These are usually put out by a recruit's family or coaches and are evaluated by college coaches. You see these more in football than hoop.
National Basketball Recruiting Analyst & Publisher of Wildcat Sports Report
Gary Randazzo ●
- 5 stars Rating: 98
2016 votes total - Gary Randazzo
- (11285)
- 33 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 5 stars
-
wineknow said...
Agreed. I saw both of them.
I don't think the problem with Josiah was his teammates. Two first team, ALL PAC-12 players and a guy who finishes as strong as just about anyone ever has (Perry). I prize a classic Point guard - BB I.Q/instincts, passing ability, court vision, leadership, ball handling... Turner was an athletic guy who happened to be decent at almost all of it (which in itself is rare) - only leadership was lacking...
But watch the Thornton video again and you'll see similar athletic ability (he's 6 years younger!), a far superior I.Q./instincts, infinitely better passing, better ball handling, better playmaking... don't what kind of leader the kid is, but he can't be worse that Toker... I mean Turner.
Turner = Shakur. 80% recruiting hype, 20% ability. He is only competent at this level because of his athletic ability and his team mates/system he plays in, not held back because of them. If he works really hard, he will play in Europe, like Shakur. He will never see a significant, meaningful minute in the NBA - he's just not got a basketball mentality or IQ.
Here is what I understand about basketball. After the requisite physical attributes and athletic ability - the ONLY thing that matters is that player have the proper mentality. You can teach a short guy to rebound (Adams), you can teach a slow guy to shoot (Kerr), you can teach a player who appeared to not care less in H.S. to become a great player (Arenas), You can teach a forward to pass (Walton), You can teach totally unknown/unheralded players to play amazing defense (McLean) and you can do all of that because and only because of their mentality/BB IQ/Attitude. But that Mentality/BB IQ/Attitude CANNOT BE TAUGHT. It could not be taught to Shakur or KNat, both of whom posses amazing physical attributes...Add Turner to that group.
-
winwithmarcusj said...
I've been knowing Derryck since he was a baby. His dad and I happen to be best friends. Derryck is a great player. He works hard in the gym and the classroom. He is a student of the game and is one of the most humble kids I know. He's a good eader and will continue to develope. He works on his game everyday. Keep your eye for him as he continues to work on and improve his game.
National Basketball Recruiting Analyst & Publisher of Wildcat Sports Report
Gary Randazzo ●
- 5 stars Rating: 98
2016 votes total - Gary Randazzo
- (11285)
- 33 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 5 stars
-
winwithmarcusj said...
I've been knowing Derryck since he was a baby. His dad and I happen to be best friends. Derryck is a great player. He works hard in the gym and the classroom. He is a student of the game and is one of the most humble kids I know. He's a good eader and will continue to develope. He works on his game everyday. Keep your eye for him as he continues to work on and improve his game.
This post was edited by wineknow on 6/6/2012 at 12:09 PM
"Arizona has no tradition" - Bill Walsh "We have a tradition of kicking Bill Walsh's ass" - Teddy Bruschi
-
BradAllis
- 5 stars Rating: 89
1086 votes total - Brad Allis
- (5363)
- 33 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 5 stars
-
Gary Randazzo ●
- 5 stars Rating: 98
2016 votes total - Gary Randazzo
- (11285)
- 33 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 5 stars
-
BradAllis
- 5 stars Rating: 89
1086 votes total - Brad Allis
- (5363)
- 33 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 5 stars

Freshman Point Guard